ISGAP Certificate Program in Critical Contemporary Antisemitism Studies

Who Defines the Jews: Jewish Identity, Minority Agency, and the Cultural Roots of Antisemitism

This course begins by asking how Jews have understood themselves, how they have been understood by the societies around them, and why those differences matter. We will look at Jewish peoplehood, the experience of living as a minority, and the limits of familiar language used in discussions about Jews and antisemitism.

The sessions will consider supersessionism and other religious interpretations in Christianity and Islam; how older ideas can continue to influence culture; how minority status may shape assimilation and self-understanding; and how Jewish history is presented in discussions about Israel. We will use a selection of readings, historical sources, photographs, and artwork—including pieces by the instructor—to look closely at examples and talk through different interpretations. The aim is to ask better questions, recognize assumptions we may take for granted, and consider parts of Jewish history and experience that often go unmentioned.

Session 1: Prisoners of Language

Why does Jewish identity so often resist the categories used to describe it, including among Jews themselves? Beginning with the differences between an ethnoreligious people and universalizing religions, this session examines Jewish peoplehood, the Diaspora, continuity with the Land of Israel, and the ways terms such as religion, race, and nationality can limit our understanding. Historical examples of emancipation and assimilation reveal how the language of a majority society can shape how a minority presents itself. Participants will consider who has the authority to name a people, and what may disappear in the naming.

Session 2: When Supersessionism Becomes Culture

Christianity and Islam emerged in relation to earlier Jewish traditions, yet developed distinct theological frameworks for understanding Jewish texts, figures, and sacred places. This session examines Christian supersessionism and the Teaching of Contempt alongside Islamic concepts of final revelation and interpretive authority, without treating the traditions or their histories as identical. It asks what the familiar label ‘Abrahamic faiths’ clarifies and what important differences it may conceal. Through texts and visual cases, we will ask how religious ideas can be inherited as cultural assumptions, even when the people repeating them no longer recognize their theological origins.

Session 3: Living as a Minority

What does life as a small minority within a majority culture do to a community’s sense of itself? Drawing on minority psychology, this session examines adaptation, assimilation, social belonging, vulnerability, and the possible internalization of external assumptions. It then turns to the changing racialization of Jews and the limitations of rigid white-versus-person-of-color frameworks. Rather than proposing a single ‘Jewish psychology,’ we will explore the varied strategies through which Jewish individuals and communities have negotiated recognition, difference, and the right to speak for themselves.

Session 4: Israel, Israel, Israel

Why does Israel occupy such a powerful place in global political and moral discourse? Building on the preceding sessions, we will consider the Jewish historical connection to the Land of Israel, the unusual position of a Jewish-majority state, and how external religious or political frameworks can recast Jewish historical memory. Selected examples will address Holocaust inversion, the persistence of anti-Jewish motifs, and regional anti-normalization. The session will also distinguish ordinary, often vigorous criticism of Israeli policy from arguments that rely on anti-Jewish stereotypes or erase Jewish collective identity. The goal is to make neglected assumptions visible and open them to informed discussion.


« Certificate Program overview

Course Details
Term:

Spring 2027

Format:

Online

Number of Sessions:

4

Dates:

March 16, March 30, April 6, April 13, 2027

Day & Times:

Tuesdays, 12:00PM - 1:00PM ET

Course Faculty
Ian Menachem Cohen

Ian Menachem Cohen is a conceptual artist and Jewish educator, whose work fuses elements of identity, history, language, story telling, and Jewish pride. His pieces can be found in private homes across the country, galleries and exhibitions. Cohen holds a Bachelor's in Jewish Studies from the City College of New York, a Master's Degree in Jewish Education from New York’s Jewish Theological Seminary’s Davidson School, a certification in Israel Education from the iCenter, and is a graduate of ISGAP’s Critical Contemporary Antisemitism Studies Certification Program.